When To Sell a Dividend Stock: Make a Smart Decision

Considering when to sell a dividend stock might sound contradictory to the value investing philosophy that practices buying and holding investments patiently and long-term.

Dividend stocks can be a favorite among income-seeking investors because they provide a steady stream of passive income, offer the potential for long-term capital appreciation, and often belong to established companies with strong financials. But not all dividend stocks are meant to be held forever.

The decision isn’t always black and white, and selling too early or too late can cost you both income and gains. In this article, we’ll break down all the key factors to consider when deciding to part ways with a dividend-paying stock and when it might be smarter to just hold on tight.

---

Affiliate

Free Dividend Kings Spreadsheet from Sure Dividend, complete with Buy/Hold/Sell recommendations, dividend histories, and much more.

---

When to Sell a Dividend Stock

1. The Company Cuts or Suspends Its Dividend

This is a major red flag. When a company reduces or eliminates its dividend, it’s essentially telling you that cash flow is tight, which is often a sign of financial trouble or declining profits. Some companies cut dividends as a strategic move to preserve cash during tough times. 

For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, several blue-chip companies such as Boeing and Disney slashed dividends to preserve cash. For some, it was temporary, but for others, it revealed deeper weaknesses. Repeated cuts often signal bigger problems. If you see a pattern of declining payments, it might be time to reassess your position and really ask yourself: has the company’s long-term outlook changed, or is this just a temporary setback?

2. Declining Fundamentals or Business Model

A good dividend isn’t worth much if the company behind it is struggling. Deteriorating financial fundamentals should also set off alarm bells. Keep an eye on key metrics like: 

• Declining revenue
• Rising debt
• Shrinking profit margins
• Poor management decisions

Outdated business model

Even if the dividend remains intact, deteriorating fundamentals may point to future dividend cuts or capital losses if the stock price starts falling. Don’t let the dividend blind you to the company’s financial health.

---

Affiliate

Portfolio Insight is a leading portfolio management and research platform.

• 9,000+ stocks and ETFs in its database
• Access up to dozens of metrics, 20-years of financial data from S&P Global, fair value, margin of safety, charting, etc.
• Avoid dividend cuts with the Dividend Quality Grade and screening tools.

Click here to try Portfolio Insight for free (14-day free trial).

---

3. The Stock Is Overvalued

If a dividend stock has appreciated significantly, it might be trading well above its intrinsic value. Valuation concerns shouldn’t be ignored. If your dividend stock has become extremely overvalued, like trading at historically high price-to-earnings ratios, then selling at a premium can lock in gains and give you room to reinvest in undervalued stocks.

In order to determine the valuation of the dividend stock, consider the following factors:

• P/E ratio compared to peers
  
• Historical valuation
  
• Analyst price targets
  

If the current yield is also low due to price appreciation, the stock might not be as attractive from an income perspective anymore. Even great companies can be poor investments if you pay too much for them.

4. Your Financial Goals or Risk Tolerance Has Changed

Any major life event or needing to free up some cash can completely change your investment strategy. Your personal circumstances matter just as much as the stock’s fundamentals. Changing investment goals might also prompt a sale. Maybe you’re nearing retirement and need to shift from growth-oriented dividend stocks to more conservative options. Or perhaps you’re young and want to allocate more money to growth stocks. Your portfolio should evolve with your life circumstances.

Selling a dividend stock may become necessary if: 

• You need to rebalance your asset allocation
  
• Your time horizon has changed
  
• You’re shifting from growth to preservation

Another reason to sell dividend stocks is because of overconcentration of risk. If one stock or sector represents too large a portion of your portfolio, you might need to trim your position regardless of the stock’s individual merits. Diversification is crucial for long-term success, and even good performing dividend stocks can experience a downturn unexpectedly. 

5. Tax Loss Harvesting

Tax considerations can influence timing. If a dividend stock is underperforming and unprofitable, you might consider selling to realize a capital loss and offset gains elsewhere in your portfolio. However, if the dividend stock is a good performer, don’t sell solely for tax reasons.

When You Should Never Sell a Dividend Stock

There are times when selling a dividend stock is the wrong move, even if you’re feeling nervous about your investment.

1. Temporary Market Volatility 

Markets go up and down, and dividend stocks are not immune to short-term fluctuations. If the underlying business remains strong and the dividend is sustainable, temporary price drops might actually represent buying opportunities rather than selling signals.

2. Minor Dividend Cuts During Crisis 

Not all dividend cuts warrant a sale. Sometimes companies make prudent decisions to temporarily reduce dividends to preserve cash during extraordinary circumstances. If the company has a strong track record, solid fundamentals, and a clear plan for dividend recovery, it’s better to be patient and not sell.

3. Short-Term Underperformance

Just because a stock underperforms for a few quarters doesn’t mean it’s unable to bounce back. Look at the bigger picture and ask yourself:

• Is the dividend still growing?
  
• Are the fundamentals intact?
  
• Is this just part of a larger industry or economic cycle?

Unless the underperformance is due to fundamental issues, selling may be premature.

Be Strategic When Selling a Dividend Stock

There are some good indicators when considering when to sell a dividend stock. Sell when the company cuts its dividend, its fundamentals deteriorate, or when your financial goals have changed. But hold the investments through short-term volatility, if the company is strong and your goals haven’t changed.

The key is to be strategic, not reactive. Dividend stocks can be a fantastic long-term wealth-building tool, but they aren’t guaranteed winners. By staying informed, not worrying about constantly changing market conditions, and evaluating financial goals regularly, you’ll know exactly when it’s time to hold and when it’s time to sell.

Related Articles on Dividend Power

• Buy Low and Sell High Strategy: A Primer for Investors
• The Smart Investor’s Playbook for Avoiding Dividend Cuts

---

Here are my recommendations:

Affiliates

• Simply Investing Report & Analysis Platform or the Course can teach you how to invest in stocks. Try it free for 14 days. 
• Free Dividend Kings Spreadsheet from Sure Dividend, complete with Buy/Hold/Sell recommendations, dividend histories, and much more. It is an excellent resource for DIY dividend growth investors and retirees.
• Stock Rover is the leading investment research platform with all the fundamental metrics, screens, and analysis tools you need. Try it free for 14 days.

---

---

Receive a free e-book, “Become a Better Investor: 5 Fundamental Metrics to Know!” Join thousands of other readers !

---

*This post contains affiliate links meaning that I earn a commission for any purchases that you make at the Affiliates website through these links. This will not incur additional costs for you. Please read my disclosure for more information.